Pathley
Build My Plan
Contact us Build My Plan
New YorkBaseball

Best Men’s Baseball Colleges in New York

New York is one of the deeper states for men’s baseball recruiting, with many roster spots across multiple NCAA levels. Use this page to compare program options, scholarship pathways, and overall college fit.

Opportunity score8.2/10Standout

Programs by level

28 of 74 play in divisions that allow athletic scholarships

At a glance

Baseball Programs in New York

74 baseball programs in New York. Tap a level to jump to its schools.

Division III has the most options here, with 46 of 74 programs (62%).

NCAA Division I

NCAA Division I Men’s Baseball Colleges in New York

New York offers a strong set of Division I men’s baseball programs, giving recruits meaningful in-state options for high-competition baseball. Expect faster recruiting timelines and a higher emphasis on measurable tools and impact roles.

Strongest programs first, by Pathley's program strength score.

BIG EAST Conference53% 5-year win rate

Big East competition, professional programs and New York City internships give athletes distinct reasons to consider studying here.

View team
Patriot League58% 5-year win rate

Athletes choose a fully funded education, competitive athletics and leadership preparation tied directly to Army service.

View team
Coastal Athletic Association46% 5-year win rate

Research opportunities, competitive athletics and in-state value give recruits several practical reasons to consider studying here.

View team

Hofstra University

Hempstead, NY

Coastal Athletic Association45% 5-year win rate

Competitive athletics, professional programs and nearby New York City give recruits several reasons to consider this campus.

View team
Northeast Conference55% 5-year win rate

Career-focused study, accessible admissions and New York professional connections complement the demands of Division I competition.

View team

NCAA Division II

NCAA Division II Men’s Baseball Colleges in New York

Division II in New York adds additional scholarship-eligible pathways while often balancing strong baseball with a more regional recruiting footprint. This level can be a fit for athletes seeking competitive play and potential athletic aid without the same D1 roster pressure.

Strongest programs first, by Pathley's program strength score.

Molloy University

Rockville Centre, NY

East Coast Conference72% 5-year win rate

Personal faculty access and career-focused programs give athletes reasons to look beyond the competition alone.

View team

Pace University

New York, NY

Northeast 10 Conference56% 5-year win rate

Career-focused academics, internship access and Division II competition give athletes reasons to consider both campus locations.

View team
East Coast Conference

Career-focused majors, a close-knit community and competitive athletics give recruits practical reasons to consider this suburban campus.

View team

Adelphi University

Garden City, NY

Northeast 10 Conference52% 5-year win rate

Personal faculty access, career-focused programs and competitive athletics make this suburban campus worth considering for recruits.

View team

Mercy University

Dobbs Ferry, NY

East Coast Conference46% 5-year win rate

Career-focused majors, accessible admissions and student support give athletes practical reasons to consider competing here.

View team

NCAA Division III

NCAA Division III Men’s Baseball Colleges in New York

New York stands out for Division III men’s baseball depth, creating a wide range of college-fit options. Since D3 does not offer athletic scholarships, recruiting is typically driven by admissions fit, academics, and a clear role on the roster.

Strongest programs first, by Pathley's program strength score.

New Jersey Athletic Conference54% 5-year win rate

Athletes choose New Paltz for demanding academics, competitive athletics, in-state value and an active Hudson Valley community.

View team

Ithaca College

Ithaca, NY

Liberty League67% 5-year win rate

Competitive athletics, hands-on academics and close mentoring appeal to recruits who want a connected college experience.

View team
State University of New York Athletic Conference71% 5-year win rate

Sports-focused academics, competitive athletics and active residential life give recruits clear reasons to consider this campus.

View team
University Athletic Association54% 5-year win rate

Strong academics, competitive athletics and New York City connections appeal to recruits seeking opportunities beyond their sport.

View team
Liberty League59% 5-year win rate

Athletes choose a technology-focused education, research opportunities and competitive athletics backed by strong graduate career outcomes.

View team

Hamilton College

Clinton, NY

New England Small College Athletic Conference50% 5-year win rate

An open curriculum, close faculty connections and competitive NESCAC athletics appeal to academically driven recruits.

View team

Free school matcher

Find the Colleges Where You Fit

Pick your position and level, and we score every baseball program on roster openings at your position, athletic level and academics.

Conferences

Conferences with New York Teams

Every baseball conference with at least one program in New York, across every division.

Liberty LeagueD3 · 11 in New YorkSkyline ConferenceD3 · 10 in New YorkEmpire 8D3 · 9 in New YorkState University of New York Athletic ConferenceD3 · 8 in New YorkEast Coast ConferenceD2 · 6 in New YorkMetro ConferenceD1 · 6 in New YorkCity University of New York Athletic ConferenceD3 · 3 in New YorkNortheast ConferenceD1 · 3 in New YorkAmerica East ConferenceD1 · 2 in New YorkAtlantic 10 ConferenceD1 · 2 in New YorkCoastal Athletic AssociationD1 · 2 in New YorkNortheast 10 ConferenceD2 · 2 in New YorkThe Ivy LeagueD1 · 2 in New YorkAllegheny Mountain Collegiate ConferenceD3 · 1 in New YorkBIG EAST ConferenceD1 · 1 in New YorkCentral Atlantic Collegiate ConferenceD2 · 1 in New YorkCity University of New York Athletic Conference (CUNYAC)D3 · 1 in New YorkNew England Small College Athletic ConferenceD3 · 1 in New YorkNew Jersey Athletic ConferenceD3 · 1 in New YorkPatriot LeagueD1 · 1 in New YorkUniversity Athletic AssociationD3 · 1 in New York

Scorecard

New York Men’s Baseball Recruiting Scorecard

This scorecard summarizes how New York stacks up for men’s baseball recruits based on in-state program availability, division coverage, scholarship-eligible options, and overall college-fit signals.

8.2/ 10

Overall opportunity score

Standout

New York is a standout state for men’s baseball recruiting thanks to exceptional program depth, strong multi-division access, and plenty of scholarship-eligible options.

Program depth

Standout
9.4/ 10

New York offers far more men’s baseball programs than a typical state, creating a deep set of in-state options for many ability levels.

Division access

Strong
7.6/ 10

With strong NCAA D1 and D3 coverage plus additional D2 options, New York provides solid division access even without NAIA programs.

Scholarship opportunity

Strong
7.8/ 10

Scholarship-eligible men’s baseball opportunities in New York are stronger than the typical state, led by a sizable D1 group and supporting D2 programs.

Academic fit

Strong
7.4/ 10

New York’s large number of programs creates many college-fit comparisons, though listed schools tend to skew a bit more selective and more expensive than typical for this sport.

Recruiting snapshot

New York Baseball Recruiting Snapshot

Who it suits, what the landscape looks like, where the money is and what gives this state an edge.

Who it suits

Recruits who want lots of in-state choices, especially those targeting Division I or prioritizing a wide range of Division III college-fit options.

The landscape

The state is deep and competitive, with many programs and a heavy D3 presence that creates plenty of roster pathways alongside high-demand D1 recruiting.

The money

Athletic scholarship opportunities are most commonly tied to D1, D2, and NAIA programs, while D3 recruiting in New York is typically more academic and fit-driven with non-athletic financial aid playing a bigger role.

The edge

New York’s dense college geography and access to major metro areas can make it easier to build a regional target list and schedule efficient campus visits and showcases.

Key metrics

Key Metrics in New York

How baseball programs in New York compare with the average state on program count, tuition, enrollment and admissions.

Programs74+230% vs average
Scholarship eligible28+88% vs average
Average tuition$34,816+19% vs average
Average enrollment7,877-7% vs average
Average acceptance rate66%-8% vs average

Three ways to start

Where are you in the search?

Pick the option that matches where you are, and we will show you the plan that fits.

Recruiting Plan

Your 20 to 25 best-fit schools, picked for you.

  • Starter: the list, fit reads, real costs and a dated timeline
  • Complete: adds roster reads and coach emails for every school
$99 or $249Starter or Complete, one time
Build my plan
Roster Report

The roster at your position, at the schools you pick.

  • Who is graduating at your position, class year by class year
  • Where spots are likely to open, in plain words
From $193, 8 or 15 schools
Choose my schools
School Plan

One school, covered end to end.

  • Your honest odds, the roster and the verified coach
  • Intro email, three follow-ups, admissions steps and timeline
$49One school, one time
Pick my school

News

Baseball: Latest News

Resources

More Resources

Sport hub

Everything for Baseball recruiting

The Baseball hub brings every division together: how D1, D2, D3 and NAIA compare, the strongest programs in each state, camps, and the recruiting guides for each level.

300D1 programs261D2 programs383D3 programs188NAIA programs
Go to the Baseball hub
Pathley Chat