Tufts University
Medford · Massachusetts · Suburban
Rigorous academics, collaborative campus life and Boston access appeal to athletes who want more than competition.
- Strength of 100
- 46
- Win rate 5-year
- 76%
Browse programs
College directoryEvery program, filtered by what fits Sport directoryMen's and women's, every division State directoryPrograms in the states you would play inGo deeper
Major directoryYour major and your sport in one list Camp directoryID camps and showcases at college programs Conference directoryEvery conference and its member collegesExplore the top overall NCAA Division III women’s softball programs, ranked for their strength across athletics, academics, and the student-athlete experience. This list helps prospective players compare well-rounded colleges that fit their goals on and off the field.
Top of the list
25 programs ranked by Top Overall



Massachusetts Institute of TechnologyCambridge, Massachusetts41StrengthBy the numbers
Every figure below is worked out from the 25 schools on this list.
The ranking
Below are the best overall NCAA Division III Women's Softball programs right now. These schools tend to combine consistent winning, strong coaching, and a competitive daily training environment that serious recruits are looking for.
Ranked by Pathley's strength score for the program, with the school's academic strength counted for 30 percent.
Medford · Massachusetts · Suburban
Rigorous academics, collaborative campus life and Boston access appeal to athletes who want more than competition.
St. Louis · Missouri · Suburban
Strong academics, close faculty relationships and competitive athletics draw recruits who want substantial challenges beyond their sport.

Cambridge · Massachusetts · Urban
Athletes choose this research-focused environment for challenging academics, collaborative peers and competitive sport in urban Cambridge.

Cleveland · Ohio · Urban
Research opportunities, strong career outcomes and urban access appeal to athletes who take academics as seriously as competition.

Williamstown · Massachusetts · Rural
Close faculty relationships, competitive athletics and generous need-based aid appeal to athletes seeking a demanding liberal arts education.

Chicago · Illinois · Urban
Rigorous academics, competitive athletics and Chicago access appeal to recruits who want intellectual challenge alongside sport.

Middlebury · Vermont · Rural
Rigorous liberal arts study, NESCAC competition and Vermont outdoor life appeal to academically ambitious athletes.

Swarthmore · Pennsylvania · Suburban
Close faculty relationships and Centennial Conference competition appeal to athletes who want demanding academics alongside their sport.
Atlanta · Georgia · Urban
Strong academics, established athletic success and Atlanta internship access appeal to recruits who want a demanding college experience.

Wellesley · Massachusetts · Suburban
Athletes choose Babson for competitive athletics, entrepreneurial learning, a close-knit community and strong business career outcomes.

Brunswick · Maine · Suburban
Rigorous academics, close mentoring and competitive NESCAC athletics appeal to recruits seeking a connected campus community.
Rochester · New York · Urban
Flexible academic choices and research opportunities appeal to athletes who want serious study alongside competitive athletics.

Waterville · Maine · Rural
Competitive NESCAC athletics, close mentoring and funded learning opportunities appeal to athletes who prioritize academic engagement.

Pittsburgh · Pennsylvania · Urban
Technical depth, competitive athletics and Pittsburgh career opportunities appeal to athletes ready for a demanding academic experience.
Ewing · New Jersey · Suburban
Undergraduate-focused teaching and NJAC competition appeal to athletes seeking a demanding education within a residential community.

Troy · New York · Suburban
Athletes choose a technology-focused education, research opportunities and competitive athletics backed by strong graduate career outcomes.

Worcester · Massachusetts · Urban
Hands-on STEM learning and competitive athletics appeal to students who want their academic and athletic commitments to matter.
Glassboro · New Jersey · Suburban
Applied academics, accessible admissions and suburban New Jersey life give athletes several reasons to consider competing here.

Amherst · Massachusetts · Rural
Athletes choose Amherst for demanding academics, close faculty relationships and competitive athletics within a small residential community.
Hoboken · New Jersey · Urban
Athletes choose Stevens for technology-focused academics, competitive athletics and career opportunities near New York City.

New Paltz · New York · Suburban
Athletes choose New Paltz for demanding academics, competitive athletics, in-state value and an active Hudson Valley community.

Middletown · Connecticut · Urban
An open curriculum and close faculty relationships appeal to athletes seeking demanding academics alongside NESCAC competition.

Oshkosh · Wisconsin · Urban
Competitive WIAC athletics and career-focused programs appeal to athletes who want their sport and education to matter.

Hartford · Connecticut · Urban
Close faculty relationships, NESCAC competition and Hartford internship opportunities appeal to athletes seeking a demanding liberal arts experience.

Bethlehem · Pennsylvania · Urban
Close faculty relationships and a welcoming campus community help athletes connect their academic goals with competitive athletics.
No school on this list is in that state.
Three ways to start
Pick the option that matches where you are, and we will show you the plan that fits.
Questions
25 programs are ranked here, from 12 states. Tufts University is ranked first.
Massachusetts (6), Pennsylvania (3), New York (3).
The average acceptance rate across the list is 30%. Admission for recruited athletes still depends on the coach's support and on meeting each school's academic standards.
The average net price, which is what families pay after grants and scholarships, is $27,562 a year. Athletic aid varies by program and division, so ask each coach what is available.
Resources
More rankings
Programs and roster openings
Sport hub
The Softball hub brings every division together: how D1, D2, D3 and NAIA compare, the strongest programs in each state, camps, and the recruiting guides for each level.