Pathley
Build My Plan
Contact us Build My Plan

Top Overall NAIA Football Colleges

NAIAMenFootballRanked by Top Overall

Explore the best NAIA men’s football programs, ranked for their overall strength across athletics, academics, and student-athlete experience. This list helps recruits compare well-rounded programs that offer competitive football and a strong college fit.

By the numbers

Top Overall NAIA Football by the Numbers

Every figure below is worked out from the 25 schools on this list.

25Schools ranked
13States represented
55%Avg graduation rate
73%Avg 5-year win rate
74%Avg acceptance rate
$53,145Avg 10-year earnings

The ranking

Top Overall NAIA Football Colleges Ranked

Here are the NAIA Men's Football programs that stand out for overall strength and consistency. These schools have a track record of winning, developing players, and competing at a high level year after year.

Ranked by Pathley's strength score for the program, with the school's academic strength counted for 30 percent.

Georgetown College

Georgetown · Kentucky · Suburban

NAIAMid-South ConferenceAccessible

Close faculty relationships and institutional scholarships complement competitive athletics within a small Christian campus community.

Strength of 100
66
Win rate 5-year
76%
View team

Lindsey Wilson University

Columbia · Kentucky · Rural

NAIAMid-South Conference

Championship experience, professional study options and a close-knit campus give athletes distinct reasons to consider Lindsey Wilson.

Strength of 100
67
Win rate 5-year
79%
View team

Indiana Wesleyan University

Marion · Indiana · Suburban

NAIACrossroads LeagueAccessible

Competitive NAIA athletics, career-focused majors and a small residential community give recruits several reasons to consider enrolling.

Strength of 100
62
Win rate 5-year
80%
View team

Keiser University

Fort Lauderdale · Florida · Urban

NAIAThe Sun Conference

Career-oriented study, flexible scheduling and successful NAIA programs appeal to athletes planning for life beyond competition.

Strength of 100
61
Win rate 5-year
83%
View team

Bethel University (Tennessee)

McKenzie · Tennessee · Rural

NAIAMid-South ConferenceModerate

Mid-South Conference competition, a small Christian campus and a relatively low net price draw athletes to Bethel.

Strength of 100
65
Win rate 5-year
73%
View team

Carroll College

Helena · Montana · Rural

NAIAFrontier ConferenceAccessible

Close faculty connections and strong health programs appeal to athletes seeking a close-knit community and competitive NAIA athletics.

Strength of 100
55
Win rate 5-year
70%
View team

Saint Xavier University

Chicago · Illinois · Urban

NAIAChicagoland Collegiate Athletic ConferenceAccessible

Competitive NAIA athletics, professional programs and available financial aid give recruits practical reasons to consider this Chicago campus.

Strength of 100
57
Win rate 5-year
67%
View team

The College of Idaho

Caldwell · Idaho · Suburban

NAIACascade Collegiate ConferenceModerate

Close faculty relationships, interdisciplinary study and NAIA competition appeal to athletes seeking a small residential college.

Strength of 100
55
Win rate 5-year
75%
View team

University of St. Francis (Illinois)

Joliet · Illinois · Suburban

NAIAChicagoland Collegiate Athletic ConferenceModerate

Strong health programs, NAIA competition and access to the Chicago area make St. Francis appealing to career-minded athletes.

Strength of 100
55
Win rate 5-year
61%
View team

Dordt University

Sioux Center · Iowa · Rural

NAIAGreat Plains Athletic ConferenceModerate

Competitive NAIA athletics, career-focused programs and a close-knit residential community give recruits distinct reasons to consider Dordt.

Strength of 100
55
Win rate 5-year
77%
View team

Morningside University

Sioux City · Iowa · Urban

NAIAGreat Plains Athletic ConferenceAccessible

Career-focused programs and a close-knit campus give athletes reasons to look beyond Morningside’s competitive athletic reputation.

Strength of 100
58
Win rate 5-year
86%
View team

Ottawa University Arizona

Surprise · Arizona · Suburban

NAIAGreat Southwest Athletic ConferenceAccessible

NAIA competition, a residential community and career-focused coursework give athletes clear reasons to consider this campus.

Strength of 100
61
Win rate 5-year
83%
View team

Northwestern College

Orange City · Iowa · Rural

NAIAGreat Plains Athletic ConferenceAccessible

Competitive NAIA athletics, career-focused programs and a small residential community give recruits several reasons to consider Northwestern.

Strength of 100
58
Win rate 5-year
83%
View team

Judson University

Elgin · Illinois · Suburban

NAIAChicagoland Collegiate Athletic ConferenceModerate

A close-knit Christian community and personal faculty access help athletes connect their sport with broader college goals.

Strength of 100
56
Acceptance
48%
View team

Olivet Nazarene University

Bourbonnais · Illinois · Suburban

NAIAChicagoland Collegiate Athletic ConferenceModerate

Athletes are drawn to NAIA competition, career-focused majors and a residential community built around Christian faith.

Strength of 100
55
Win rate 5-year
63%
View team

Montana Technological University

Butte · Montana · Rural

NAIAFrontier ConferenceAccessible

Athletes come for career-focused academics, Frontier Conference competition and a small campus with outdoor recreation nearby.

Strength of 100
56
Win rate 5-year
71%
View team

Campbellsville University

Campbellsville · Kentucky · Rural

NAIAMid-South ConferenceAccessible

A Christian campus community and career-focused majors give athletes reasons to look beyond their athletic fit.

Strength of 100
62
Acceptance
80%
View team

Cumberland University

Lebanon · Tennessee · Suburban

NAIAMid-South ConferenceModerate

A small-campus community and career-focused academics offer a practical foundation for athletes pursuing NAIA competition.

Strength of 100
54
Win rate 5-year
49%
View team

Marian University

Indianapolis · Indiana · Urban

NAIAMid-States Football AssociationAccessible

Competitive athletics, approachable faculty and city internship opportunities give recruits reasons to look closely at Marian.

Strength of 100
54
Win rate 5-year
77%
View team

Dickinson State University

Dickinson · North Dakota · Rural

NAIAFrontier ConferenceSelective

A small campus, practical academic programs and regional career connections appeal to athletes balancing competition with college.

Strength of 100
55
Win rate 5-year
70%
View team

Benedictine College

Atchison · Kansas · Rural

NAIAHeart of America Athletic ConferenceAccessible

A close-knit Catholic community and NAIA competition appeal to athletes seeking connection alongside their academic goals.

Strength of 100
52
Win rate 5-year
78%
View team

Texas Wesleyan University

Fort Worth · Texas · Urban

NAIASooner Athletic ConferenceModerate

Small classes, accessible admissions and NAIA competition give athletes a personal college experience within urban Fort Worth.

Strength of 100
56
Win rate 5-year
76%
View team

Evangel University

Springfield · Missouri · Urban

NAIAKansas Collegiate Athletic ConferenceAccessible

Accessible admissions, personal faculty connections and professional majors give athletes practical reasons to consider competing here.

Strength of 100
52
Win rate 5-year
73%
View team

Taylor University

Upland · Indiana · Rural

NAIACrossroads LeagueAccessible

Faith-centered community, accessible faculty and NAIA competition give athletes a connected college experience beyond their sport.

Strength of 100
48
Win rate 5-year
48%
View team

University of Montana Western

Dillon · Montana · Rural

NAIAFrontier ConferenceAccessible

Block scheduling, hands-on academics and Frontier Conference competition appeal to athletes seeking a small Montana campus.

Strength of 100
56
Win rate 5-year
73%
View team

Three ways to start

Where are you in the search?

Pick the option that matches where you are, and we will show you the plan that fits.

Recruiting Plan

Your 20 to 25 best-fit schools, picked for you.

  • Starter: the list, fit reads, real costs and a dated timeline
  • Complete: adds roster reads and coach emails for every school
$99 or $249Starter or Complete, one time
Build my plan
Roster Report

The roster at your position, at the schools you pick.

  • Who is graduating at your position, class year by class year
  • Where spots are likely to open, in plain words
From $193, 8 or 15 schools
Choose my schools
School Plan

One school, covered end to end.

  • Your honest odds, the roster and the verified coach
  • Intro email, three follow-ups, admissions steps and timeline
$49One school, one time
Pick my school

Questions

About this list

How many NAIA Football programs are on this list?

25 programs are ranked here, from 13 states. Georgetown College is ranked first.

Which states have the most schools on this list?

Illinois (4), Kentucky (3), Indiana (3).

How hard is it to get into these schools?

The average acceptance rate across the list is 74%. Admission for recruited athletes still depends on the coach's support and on meeting each school's academic standards.

What do these schools cost?

The average net price, which is what families pay after grants and scholarships, is $20,672 a year. Athletic aid varies by program and division, so ask each coach what is available.

Resources

Keep exploring

Sport hub

Everything for Football recruiting

The Football hub brings every division together: how D1, D2, D3 and NAIA compare, the strongest programs in each state, camps, and the recruiting guides for each level.

257D1 programs167D2 programs242D3 programs96NAIA programs
Go to the Football hub
Pathley Chat