Pathley
Build My Plan
Contact us Build My Plan
Earlham College Men's Soccer
NCAA Division IIIHeartland Collegiate Athletic ConferenceIndiana

Earlham College Men's Soccer

One plan built for Earlham College Men's Soccer, with the roster read, the coach's contact and a dated plan, delivered within 24 hours. An expert checks every plan.

32
Roster
1
Leaving
9%
In-state
0%
Transfers

Overview

Earlham College Men's Soccer Team Details

Key facts about the Earlham College men's soccer team.

From its campus in Richmond, Indiana, Earlham College competes in Division III men's soccer as a member of the Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference. It is a young group, with 15 of 32 players in their first year. Over five seasons it has a 23% winning percentage, in the bottom 10% among Division III men's soccer teams.

NCAA Division IIIHeartland Collegiate Athletic ConferenceIndiana
Head coach
Aaron Gustine

Head Men's Soccer Coach

Home venue
Matlack-Messer Soccer Stadium
Average roster
30

players a season

Five-year win rate
23%

Fit check

Do You Fit at Earlham College?

Pick your position and level, add a test score if you have one, and get an instant read on your chances here. Free, and no account needed.

Coaching staff

Get on This Staff's Radar

Roster

Roster Breakdown

The roster by class

15FreshmenFr.
5SophomoresSo.
11JuniorsJr.
1SeniorsSr.

32 players on the latest roster (2026).

Roster openings after 2026-27

1players in their final year, 3% of the roster

Midfielder 1

See who you would be replacing

A young group: 47% of the roster is in its first year, with 62% made up of freshmen and sophomores together.

Positions

Men's Soccer Roster by Position

How many players a season the program carries at each position, and how tall they are.

Goalkeeper
2.7players a season
Defender
8players a season
Midfielder
13.7players a season
Forward
5.7players a season

Midfielders are a larger part of this roster than usual, at 46% versus 35% for the average Division III men's soccer team.

Footprint

Where This Team Recruits

Where the players are from

90players
In-state8.9%
Other US states81.1%
International10%

Counted from players on recent rosters with a known hometown.

Top home states

Ohio16%
Kentucky9%
Indiana9%
Illinois8%
Maryland8%

Out-of-state recruits dominate, since only 9% of the roster comes from Indiana, versus 48% for the median team among Division III men's soccer teams.

Results

Earlham College Men's Soccer Recent Results

2021

0%

0-16overall

0-9conference

2022

22%

3-12-1overall

1-8conference

Best season

2023

35%

4-9-4overall

2-5-2conference

2024

29%

4-11-2overall

3-5-1conference

Latest

2025

26%

3-11-3overall

2-6-1conference

The program has a 23% winning percentage over the last five seasons, which falls in the bottom 10% among Division III men's soccer teams, where the median is 51%.

Standings

Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference Standings

Where Earlham College stands in the Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference.

Schedule and travel

Men's Soccer Schedule

The season's games, home and away, and how far the team travels.

Recruiting

Recruiting Outlook

Earlham men's soccer is an NCAA Division III program competing in the Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference. The program has a documented history that includes an HCAC championship and an NCAA Championship appearance, but its most recent confirmed season was more competitive at the conference level than nationally prominent. The roster includes players from a wide range of club and developmental backgrounds, so recruits who combine technical ability, positional flexibility, and academic fit may find a realistic pathway to the program.

NCAA Division III HCAC programRecent roster includes extensive club-soccer experienceEstablished postseason history with an HCAC title and NCAA appearance

Recruiting difficulty

40/ 100
OpenCompetitiveSelectiveElite

The program is moderately competitive, with recruited players making up much of the roster while Division III structure can leave room for developing athletes who fit specific positional needs.

What coaches value

  • Technical quality under pressure, including first touch, passing speed, and decision-making in tight spaces
  • Tactical awareness and positional discipline, especially in defensive transition and team shape
  • Reliable athletic habits such as work rate, repeat running, recovery effort, and physical competitiveness
  • Versatility, coachability, and the ability to contribute across multiple roles

How to get recruited here

Create a concise recruiting profile with match film, position, height, graduation year, academic information, club schedule, and contact details. Send coaches a personalized email before showcase events, then follow up with updated film and verified schedule information so they can evaluate you in person.

How hard is it to make the team

Making Earlham's men's soccer team is competitive but not comparable to an elite national Division III program. The roster is substantial and includes players with club experience from several regions, so recruits should show clear technical strengths and tactical reliability, while developing athletes may improve their chances through positional flexibility, consistency, and strong training habits.

Who fits this program

  • Soccer players seeking an accessible Division III pathway in the HCAC
  • Athletes who value small classes and a 7:1 student-faculty ratio
  • Students preferring a rural campus and small-city lifestyle
  • Players with club experience, technical ability, and positional flexibility

Videos

Earlham College Men's Soccer Videos

Men's Soccer vs. Earlham 9.16.23
EARLHAM MEN'S SOCCER VS. OTTEREIN
EARLHAM MEN'S SOCCER VS. FRANKLIN

Program stats

The Program by the Numbers

32

Athletes on the roster

3

Coaches on staff

$1,353

Spent per athlete

Spending and revenue a year

Spending$209,458
Revenue$209,458

Revenue covers everything the program spends.

Source: the federal Equity in Athletics report, 2025.

Feeders

Top Feeder Schools and Clubs

The high schools and clubs that sent the most players to this roster.

1FC Pride4 players on recent rosters
2Ohio Galaxies3 players on recent rosters
3Cincinnati United Premier2 players on recent rosters
4Go Premier2 players on recent rosters
5Hoover-Vestavia SC2 players on recent rosters

If there is one pipeline to know, it is FC Pride, which has sent four players onto recent rosters. Beyond one-off arrivals, five sources keep sending players, with at least two apiece.

The school

School Environment

Earlham College pairs liberal arts study with collaborative research and applied learning, making faculty access, academic expectations and career direction important considerations as you plan to balance coursework with athletics.

Earlham College campusEarlham CollegeRichmond, IndianaSee the full profile
73%

Acceptance rate

69%

Graduation rate

Undergraduates
696
Net price a year
$24,714
Earnings after ten years
$50,797

Similar programs

Similar Soccer Teams

Programs at a similar level, with similar academics, worth adding to your recruiting list.

Franklin College

Franklin, IN

Why it is similar: Same conference and state.
Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference24% 5-year win rate

A small-campus community, reachable faculty and Indianapolis connections give athletes reasons to look closely at Franklin.

View team

Mount St. Joseph University

Cincinnati, OH

Why it is similar: Same conference.
Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference24% 5-year win rate

Personal attention, career-focused learning and a supportive Catholic community give athletes reasons to consider the Mount.

View team

University of Dallas

Irving, TX

Why it is similar: Similar level and academics.
Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference16% 5-year win rate

Close mentoring, a shared intellectual foundation and competitive athletics appeal to students who value learning alongside sport.

View team

Immaculata University

Immaculata, PA

Why it is similar: Similar level and academics.
Atlantic East Conference39% 5-year win rate

Personal faculty connections, accessible admissions and a close-knit Catholic community complement the Atlantic East athletic experience.

View team

Coe College

Cedar Rapids, IA

Why it is similar: Similar level and academics.
American Rivers Conference31% 5-year win rate

Close faculty connections and career-focused experiences give athletes reasons to look beyond the playing field.

View team

Penn State Berks

Reading, PA

Why it is similar: Similar level and academics.
United East Conference24% 5-year win rate

Close faculty relationships and a residential community give athletes a smaller setting for balancing academics and competition.

View team

Teams in Indiana

More Soccer Teams in Indiana

DePauw University

Greencastle, IN

North Coast Athletic Conference58% 5-year win rate

Close faculty relationships and a residential community appeal to athletes who want demanding academics alongside competitive athletics.

View team

Franklin College

Franklin, IN

Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference24% 5-year win rate

A small-campus community, reachable faculty and Indianapolis connections give athletes reasons to look closely at Franklin.

View team

Hanover College

Hanover, IN

Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference66% 5-year win rate

Close faculty mentorship and a riverside campus appeal to athletes seeking a small-college experience alongside conference competition.

View team

Manchester University

North Manchester, IN

Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference46% 5-year win rate

A residential community and approachable faculty help athletes connect their college experience with academic and career goals.

View team
Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference68% 5-year win rate

Hands-on STEM learning, personal faculty access and competitive athletics appeal to recruits with clear technical career goals.

View team
Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association47% 5-year win rate

Competitive athletics, practical academics and a close-knit campus give recruits reasons to look closely at Trine.

View team

Roster openings · 2026-27

Which D3 Men's Soccer programs have the most roster spots opening up?

Every program ranked by players in their final year, with the positions they are losing.

6.6players leaving per program, on average
See the programs

Three ways to start

Where are you in the search?

Pick the option that matches where you are, and we will show you the plan that fits.

Recruiting Plan

Your 20 to 25 best-fit schools, picked for you.

  • Starter: the list, fit reads, real costs and a dated timeline
  • Complete: adds roster reads and coach emails for every school
$99 or $249Starter or Complete, one time
Build my plan
Roster Report

The roster at your position, at the schools you pick.

  • Who is graduating at your position, class year by class year
  • Where spots are likely to open, in plain words
From $193, 8 or 15 schools
Choose my schools
School Plan

One school, covered end to end.

  • Your honest odds, the roster and the verified coach
  • Intro email, three follow-ups, admissions steps and timeline
$49One school, one time
Pick my school

Resources

Additional Resources

Pathley Chat