Pathley
Build My Plan
Contact us Build My Plan
Otterbein University Softball
NCAA Division IIIOhio Athletic ConferenceOhio

Otterbein University Softball

One plan built for Otterbein University Softball, with the roster read, the coach's contact and a dated plan, delivered within 24 hours. An expert checks every plan.

23
Roster
0%
In-state

Overview

Otterbein University Softball Team Details

Key facts about the Otterbein University softball team.

From its campus in Westerville, Ohio, Otterbein University competes in Division III softball as a member of the Ohio Athletic Conference. The roster is stable, with 90% of last season's non-seniors back, above the 82% median among Division III softball teams.

NCAA Division IIIOhio Athletic ConferenceOhio
Head coach
Bruce Anderson

Head Coach

Home venue
Softball Field
Average roster
23

players a season

Five-year win rate
45%

Fit check

Do You Fit at Otterbein University?

Pick your position and level, add a test score if you have one, and get an instant read on your chances here. Free, and no account needed.

Coaching staff

Get on This Staff's Radar

Roster

Roster Breakdown

The roster by class

8FreshmenFr.
9SophomoresSo.
4JuniorsJr.
6SeniorsSr.

27 players on the latest roster (2026).

Continuity is a strength, with 90% of last season's non-seniors back, ahead of the 82% median among Division III softball teams. Players who stay tend to build roles, so newcomers may need patience.

Positions

Softball Roster by Position

How many players a season the program carries at each position, and how tall they are.

Pitcher
4players a season
Catcher
3players a season
Infielder
9.3players a season
Outfielder
3.3players a season
Utility/Designated Hitter
3.7players a season

Outfielders make up just 14% of the roster, about three per season, light compared with the 22% average among Division III softball teams. Among Division III softball teams, few teams lean harder on infielders, which fill 40% of the roster versus an average of 31%.

Footprint

Where This Team Recruits

Where the players are from

7players
In-state0%
Other US states100%
International0%

Counted from players on recent rosters with a known hometown.

Top home states

Michigan43%
Pennsylvania29%
Illinois29%

Out-of-state recruits make up the whole roster, since nobody comes from Ohio, versus a median of 56% among Division III softball teams.

Results

Otterbein University Softball Recent Results

Best season

2022

64%

23-13overall

10-8conference

2023

49%

16-17-1overall

9-9conference

2024

39%

14-22overall

7-11conference

2025

45%

14-17overall

5-10conference

Latest

2026

29%

11-27overall

2-14conference

A winning season has not come since 2023, with a 40% winning percentage over that run. Win rate fell to 29% in the 2026 season, an 11-27 finish and the lowest of the last five seasons.

Standings

Ohio Athletic Conference Standings

Where Otterbein University stands in the Ohio Athletic Conference.

Schedule and travel

Softball Schedule

The season's games, home and away, and how far the team travels.

Recruiting

Recruiting Outlook

Who fits this program

  • Competes in Ohio Athletic Conference at NCAA Division III level
  • Supports balancing softball with moderate academic workload
  • Small suburban campus fosters close-knit team and community culture
  • Ideal for softball players focused on consistent development and engagement

Program stats

The Program by the Numbers

26

Athletes on the roster

3

Coaches on staff

$1,934

Spent per athlete

Spending and revenue a year

Spending$114,110
Revenue$129,141

Revenue covers everything the program spends.

The team spends about $1,500 per athlete on operations in the 2025 EADA report, about half of the Division III median, and reports revenue about 13% above expenses in the same report.

Source: the federal Equity in Athletics report, 2025.

Feeders

Top Feeder Schools and Clubs

The high schools and clubs that sent the most players to this roster.

1West Holmes High School2 players on recent rosters

The school

School Environment

Otterbein University's blend of liberal arts and professional programs gives athletes several academic directions to explore, with undergraduate teaching, faculty access and career preparation central to evaluating the fit.

Otterbein University campusOtterbein UniversityWesterville, OhioSee the full profile
85%

Acceptance rate

68%

Graduation rate

Undergraduates
2,211
Net price a year
$19,237
Earnings after ten years
$53,313

Similar programs

Similar Softball Teams

Programs at a similar level, with similar academics, worth adding to your recruiting list.

Ohio Northern University

Ada, OH

Why it is similar: Same conference and state.
Ohio Athletic Conference49% 5-year win rate

Professional programs, reachable faculty and a small residential community give athletes clear reasons to consider competing here.

View team

Earlham College

Richmond, IN

Why it is similar: Similar level and academics.
Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference52% 5-year win rate

Close mentoring, Quaker community values and competitive athletics appeal to students seeking a connected college experience.

View team

Wittenberg University

Springfield, OH

Why it is similar: Also in Ohio.
North Coast Athletic Conference51% 5-year win rate

Close faculty relationships and a residential community give athletes room to pursue academics, competition and leadership.

View team

Juniata College

Huntingdon, PA

Why it is similar: Similar level and academics.
Landmark Conference43% 5-year win rate

Personalized academics, close faculty relationships and a small residential community complement the commitment to Division III competition.

View team

Teams in Ohio

More Softball Teams in Ohio

Ohio Athletic Conference62% 5-year win rate

Competitive athletics, performing arts and nearby Cleveland opportunities appeal to athletes seeking a small-campus experience.

View team
Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference31% 5-year win rate

A close-knit campus, reachable faculty and conference competition give athletes a personal setting for college life.

View team

Capital University

Columbus, OH

Ohio Athletic Conference41% 5-year win rate

Close faculty relationships and access to Columbus internships complement a small-campus experience and competitive Division III athletics.

View team
University Athletic Association76% 5-year win rate

Research opportunities, strong career outcomes and urban access appeal to athletes who take academics as seriously as competition.

View team
North Coast Athletic Conference47% 5-year win rate

Close faculty mentoring and a residential community help athletes connect demanding academics with Division III competition.

View team

Denison University

Granville, OH

North Coast Athletic Conference56% 5-year win rate

Close faculty relationships and a residential community appeal to athletes seeking challenging academics alongside conference competition.

View team

Roster openings

Which D3 Softball programs have the most roster spots opening up?

Every program ranked by players in their final year, with the positions they are losing.

4.5players leaving per program, on average
See the programs

Three ways to start

Where are you in the search?

Pick the option that matches where you are, and we will show you the plan that fits.

Recruiting Plan

Your 20 to 25 best-fit schools, picked for you.

  • Starter: the list, fit reads, real costs and a dated timeline
  • Complete: adds roster reads and coach emails for every school
$99 or $249Starter or Complete, one time
Build my plan
Roster Report

The roster at your position, at the schools you pick.

  • Who is graduating at your position, class year by class year
  • Where spots are likely to open, in plain words
From $193, 8 or 15 schools
Choose my schools
School Plan

One school, covered end to end.

  • Your honest odds, the roster and the verified coach
  • Intro email, three follow-ups, admissions steps and timeline
$49One school, one time
Pick my school

Resources

Additional Resources

Pathley Chat