Pathley
Build My Plan
Contact us Build My Plan
John Jay College of Criminal Justice Softball
NCAA Division IIICity University of New York Athletic ConferenceNew York

John Jay College of Criminal Justice Softball

One plan built for John Jay College of Criminal Justice Softball, with the roster read, the coach's contact and a dated plan, delivered within 24 hours. An expert checks every plan.

17
Roster
44%
In-state

Overview

John Jay College of Criminal Justice Softball Team Details

Key facts about the John Jay College of Criminal Justice softball team.

John Jay College of Criminal Justice runs a softball team in New York, New York, competing in the City University of New York Athletic Conference at the Division III level. It is an experienced group, with six of 14 players seniors or graduate students. Win rate dropped 28 points, from 30-11 in 2025 to 18-22 in 2026.

NCAA Division IIICity University of New York Athletic ConferenceNew York
Head coach
Sarah Piening

Head Coach

Home venue
Cougar Softball Field (Kean University)
Average roster
17

players a season

Five-year win rate
59%

Fit check

Do You Fit at John Jay College of Criminal Justice?

Pick your position and level, add a test score if you have one, and get an instant read on your chances here. Free, and no account needed.

Coaching staff

Get on This Staff's Radar

Head coach

Sarah PieningHead Coach
Email●●●●●●@●●●●.edu
Phone(●●●) ●●●-●●●●
Get the coach's contact

Roster

Roster Breakdown

The roster by class

1FreshmenFr.
3SophomoresSo.
4JuniorsJr.
5SeniorsSr.
1GraduateGrad

14 players on the latest roster (2026).

Experience runs deep, with six of 14 players seniors or graduate students, 43% of the roster. Those players will leave soon, which tends to open spots for the next class.

Positions

Softball Roster by Position

How many players a season the program carries at each position, and how tall they are.

Pitcher
3.7players a season

Average height 5'5"

Catcher
2players a season

Average height 5'4"

Infielder
4.3players a season

Average height 5'7"

Outfielder
5players a season

Average height 5'3"

Utility/Designated Hitter
2.3players a season

Average height 5'3"

The outfielders group is bigger than usual, at 29% of the roster compared with an average of 22% among Division III softball teams.

Footprint

Where This Team Recruits

Where the players are from

52players
In-state44.2%
Other US states55.8%
International0%

Counted from players on recent rosters with a known hometown.

Top home states

New York44%
New Jersey15%
Nevada6%
Florida6%
Kansas6%

Coaches draw from a wide map. Just 77% of players come from the five largest source states, well under the 91% median among Division III softball teams.

Results

John Jay College of Criminal Justice Softball Recent Results

2022

45%

17-21overall

14-6conference

2023

60%

26-17overall

8-2conference

2024

70%

32-14overall

9-1conference

Best season

2025

73%

30-11overall

10-0conference

Latest

2026

45%

18-22overall

8-2conference

After going 30-11 in 2025, this team finished 18-22 in 2026, a step back of 28 points in winning percentage. At the same time, an 8-2 record in City University of New York Athletic Conference play in 2026 stood out against an 18-22 record overall.

Standings

City University of New York Athletic Conference Standings

Where John Jay College of Criminal Justice stands in the City University of New York Athletic Conference.

Schedule and travel

Softball Schedule

The season's games, home and away, and how far the team travels.

Recruiting

Recruiting Outlook

Who fits this program

  • Competes in NCAA Division III CUNYAC conference level
  • Maintains moderate academic difficulty alongside athletic commitment
  • Urban commuter campus offers diverse cultural and professional access
  • Ideal for softball athletes focused on justice-related career goals

Program stats

The Program by the Numbers

21

Athletes on the roster

3

Coaches on staff

$3,849

Spent per athlete

Spending and revenue a year

Spending$112,139
Revenue$112,139

Revenue covers everything the program spends.

Source: the federal Equity in Athletics report, 2025.

The school

School Environment

John Jay College of Criminal Justice combines a justice-focused academic identity with broad liberal arts study, making course demands, faculty access and degree completion important considerations for prospective student-athletes.

John Jay College of Criminal Justice campusJohn Jay College of Criminal JusticeNew York, New YorkSee the full profile
57%

Acceptance rate

56%

Graduation rate

Undergraduates
11,942
Net price a year
$3,203
Earnings after ten years
$56,195

Similar programs

Similar Softball Teams

Programs at a similar level, with similar academics, worth adding to your recruiting list.

Brooklyn College

Brooklyn, NY

Why it is similar: Same conference and state.
City University of New York Athletic Conference37% 5-year win rate

Affordable study, broad academic choices and city career access give athletes practical reasons to pursue this campus.

View team

Buffalo State University

Buffalo, NY

Why it is similar: Also in New York.
State University of New York Athletic Conference55% 5-year win rate

Accessible admissions, public tuition and community-connected learning give athletes practical reasons to consider competing here.

View team

Utica University

Utica, NY

Why it is similar: Also in New York.
Empire 852% 5-year win rate

Career-focused programs and close faculty contact give athletes practical reasons to consider this small university.

View team

Mount Saint Mary College

Newburgh, NY

Why it is similar: Also in New York.
Skyline Conference49% 5-year win rate

Close faculty connections and career-focused academics give athletes a practical foundation alongside Skyline Conference competition.

View team

Teams in New York

More Softball Teams in New York

State University of New York Athletic Conference36% 5-year win rate

Hands-on academics, SUNY affordability and a small residential community give athletes practical reasons to pursue this campus.

View team
Empire 867% 5-year win rate

Small classes, hands-on academics and Division III competition appeal to athletes seeking a close-knit residential college experience.

View team

Elmira College

Elmira, NY

Empire 843% 5-year win rate

Close faculty connections and a small campus help athletes build an academic identity alongside their sport.

View team

Hamilton College

Clinton, NY

New England Small College Athletic Conference44% 5-year win rate

An open curriculum, close faculty connections and competitive NESCAC athletics appeal to academically driven recruits.

View team

Hartwick College

Oneonta, NY

Empire 814% 5-year win rate

Close faculty relationships, experiential learning and Division III competition give athletes a connected college experience.

View team

Hilbert College

Hamburg, NY

Allegheny Mountain Collegiate Conference30% 5-year win rate

Career-focused majors, accessible admissions and a close-knit campus give athletes practical reasons to consider competing here.

View team

Roster openings

Which D3 Softball programs have the most roster spots opening up?

Every program ranked by players in their final year, with the positions they are losing.

4.5players leaving per program, on average
See the programs

Three ways to start

Where are you in the search?

Pick the option that matches where you are, and we will show you the plan that fits.

Recruiting Plan

Your 20 to 25 best-fit schools, picked for you.

  • Starter: the list, fit reads, real costs and a dated timeline
  • Complete: adds roster reads and coach emails for every school
$99 or $249Starter or Complete, one time
Build my plan
Roster Report

The roster at your position, at the schools you pick.

  • Who is graduating at your position, class year by class year
  • Where spots are likely to open, in plain words
From $193, 8 or 15 schools
Choose my schools
School Plan

One school, covered end to end.

  • Your honest odds, the roster and the verified coach
  • Intro email, three follow-ups, admissions steps and timeline
$49One school, one time
Pick my school

Resources

Additional Resources

Pathley Chat