For most men’s and women’s soccer recruits, it is generally harder to earn an athletic scholarship at NCAA Division II than at the NAIA, assuming you are the same player asking for the same amount of money. Division II programs tend to recruit from a deeper talent pool and operate under stricter NCAA rules, while many NAIA schools have more flexibility to offer small-to-medium athletic awards to a wider range of players.
Why NCAA Division II soccer scholarships are usually harder to earn
- Higher average level of play: Many D2 programs recruit strong domestic and international players who are already close to college game speed, physically and tactically.
- More competition for roster spots: Coaches often get a large number of quality emails and referrals for each position, so they can be selective.
- NCAA rules and structure: Eligibility, amateurism, and recruiting rules add friction. Coaches may move slower, watch more full-game film, and are less likely to take a chance on borderline players.
- Scholarship budgets used on proven impact players: With limited equivalency scholarships, many D2 staffs concentrate money on players they expect to contribute early.
Why NAIA soccer scholarships are often easier to get
- Flexibility in packaging aid: NAIA coaches frequently combine smaller athletic awards with academic (merit) scholarships and institutional grants to build a total package.
- Faster decisions: With fewer recruiting restrictions than the NCAA, NAIA staffs can offer earlier and respond more quickly to film and emails.
- More partial awards spread across the roster: It’s common for NAIA programs to give some athletic money to a large portion of the team, even if full rides are rare.
- Willingness to recruit developmental players: Many NAIA coaches are open to players who are a bit below NCAA speed but have a clear upside, strong academics, or a positional “hook” (for example, a tall left-footed center back or an experienced goalkeeper).
The key distinction: any scholarship vs a big scholarship
- Any athletic money: If your goal is simply to get on the board with some athletic aid, NAIA is usually more realistic for mid-level recruits.
- A large athletic scholarship: Bigger awards can be difficult at both levels. Some D2 schools may have more total resources, but they reserve those dollars for players who clearly look like high-level starters. Top NAIA programs do the same.
How coaches actually use your film at each level
- At NAIA schools: A strong highlight plus at least one full game that shows you can handle their tempo will often be enough to earn a partial offer if you fit a roster need.
- At NCAA Division II schools: Full-game film is critical. Highlights might get interest, but coaches typically want to see how you defend, move, and think for 90 minutes before they talk scholarship numbers.
What this means for your recruiting strategy If you are a solid player who may be a little below typical NCAA D2 speed or experience, NAIA is often the more realistic path to get some athletic money and meaningful playing time. However, value-focused NCAA D2 public schools can sometimes produce a better overall cost even with smaller soccer money, especially if their tuition is lower for out-of-state or international students.
A smart approach for many recruits is to pursue both:
- Build a list of NAIA programs where you could play early and stack athletic + academic aid.
- Add some realistic NCAA Division II options (often smaller or regional publics) where your film suggests you can compete.
Ultimately, the level where it’s “harder” for you depends on your verified game level, position, academics, and how well you target schools that match your current ability and budget.


