College Search
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
College Search
On February 6, 2026, Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey wrestling turned Jersey Mike’s Arena in Piscataway into the backdrop for one of the program’s defining nights. Ranked No. 17 nationally, the Scarlet Knights stormed past No. 6 Minnesota 23–15, delivering a Big Ten upset that instantly reshaped how the 2025–26 season – and the trajectory of Rutgers wrestling – will be remembered.
In front of 3,702 fans, Rutgers rattled off six wins in ten bouts, including two major decisions and a dual-clinching pin at 197 pounds. The victory pushed Rutgers to 11–5 overall and 4–3 in the Big Ten and, just as importantly, marked the Scarlet Knights’ first-ever dual win over Minnesota, one of college wrestling’s traditional powerhouses.
The 23–15 result was also Rutgers’ first win over a top-six opponent since edging No. 4 Nebraska by a single point at home back in December 2015. Local coverage quickly framed Minnesota as the highest-ranked team Rutgers has beaten in roughly a decade, and national outlets echoed the idea that this was a benchmark moment for the program.
From the opening whistle, Rutgers made it clear this would not be a routine February dual. At 125 pounds, Ayden Smith drew Minnesota’s Jore Volk, a 2024 All-American and top-10 nationally ranked wrestler. On paper, the Golden Gophers had a clear edge. On the mat, Smith flipped that script.
Smith attacked early, securing a first-period takedown that immediately put pressure on Volk. As time wound down, Volk surged, closing the gap and threatening to swing momentum back toward the visitors. Instead, Smith answered with a decisive re-attack, finishing another takedown and closing out a 7–2 decision.
That upset did much more than put three points on the board. It gave Rutgers a 3–0 lead and ignited the New Brunswick–Piscataway crowd that routinely turns Jersey Mike’s Arena into one of the more underrated environments in college wrestling. For a fan base that has watched the Scarlet Knights work to climb the Big Ten ladder, Smith’s performance at 125 felt like a statement that Rutgers was ready to challenge a top-six power across all ten weights.
Rutgers doubled down quickly. At 133 pounds, Dylan Shawver followed Smith’s upset with one of the night’s most valuable team results. Facing Minnesota’s Brandon Morvari, Shawver used relentless pressure, steady hand-fighting, and constant attacks to rack up points. By the final whistle, he had put together a 12–2 major decision.
That four-point team swing extended the Scarlet Knights’ lead to 7–0 and underscored how critical the lightweights can be in a Big Ten dual. In a conference where every bonus point can shape postseason seeding and national polls, Shawver’s ability to turn a likely win into a major decision gave Rutgers breathing room and confidence.
Minnesota answered at 141 pounds behind standout Vance VomBaur, who earned a technical fall over Rutgers’ Mason Gibson. That narrowed the margin to 7–5 and could have marked a turning point. Instead, Rutgers stabilized the dual with two pivotal victories heading into the middle of the lineup.
At 149 pounds, Andrew Clark delivered a composed, methodical 5–1 decision over Minnesota’s Drew Roberts, another ranked opponent. Clark’s early takedown and strong riding-time advantage kept Roberts on the defensive and restored Rutgers’ momentum. Then, at 157 pounds, Anthony White found himself in a tight, low-scoring battle with Charlie Millard. Tied 1–1 after regulation, White capitalized in sudden victory, finishing a quick takedown to secure a 4–1 win.
Those back-to-back wins at 149 and 157 did more than add six points to the team score. They represented Rutgers beating multiple ranked Golden Gopher opponents in a single night, a hallmark of programs that are ready to move from competitive to nationally relevant. With four wins in the first five bouts, Rutgers rolled into the midpoint with a commanding 13–5 advantage and forced Minnesota into uncomfortable catch-up mode.
The dual tightened somewhat as the teams moved into the middleweights, but Rutgers continued to manage the scoreboard with tactical discipline. At 165 pounds, Minnesota’s Andrew Sparks earned a 2–0 decision over Rutgers’ Andrew Barbosa. The Gophers chipped into the lead, but the result did not radically change the overall picture. The Scarlet Knights still controlled the dual, and Minnesota would need multiple high-value, bonus-point wins to claw all the way back.
That context magnified the importance of the 174-pound matchup, where Rutgers’ Lenny Pinto produced one of the most dominant individual efforts of the evening. From the opening whistle, Pinto was on the attack against Minnesota’s Ethan Riddle, using pace and varied attacks to break the match open. By the end, he secured an 18–9 major decision, another four-point result that had major implications for the team score.
Pinto’s bonus points pushed Rutgers ahead 17–8 and shifted even more pressure onto Minnesota’s upper weights. The path was clear: the Golden Gophers would now need an almost perfect run through the final three bouts, with multiple majors or better, to have a shot at stealing the dual in hostile territory.
Minnesota got the kind of performance it needed at 184 pounds from All-American Max McEnelly. Facing Rutgers’ Shane Cartagena-Walsh, McEnelly brought the aggressive offense that has made him one of the Big Ten’s most dangerous middleweights. He rolled to a 15–7 major decision, cutting the team score to 17–12 and keeping the dual very much in play with two matches left.
That set up a pressure-packed showdown at 197 pounds, arguably the pivotal bout of the night. Rutgers sent out No. 16 Remy Cotton, while Minnesota countered with No. 25 Gavin Nelson. The rankings signaled a tight matchup, and the reality on the mat matched that expectation.
The bout was tense, low-scoring, and physical. After seven minutes, the wrestlers were locked in a 1–1 tie, and Jersey Mike’s Arena buzzed as the dual came down to sudden victory. With both benches on their feet and the outcome hanging in the balance, Cotton created the moment Rutgers fans will remember for years.
In overtime, he capitalized on a scramble, turned Nelson to his back, and finished the fall at the 8:13 mark. The pin instantly clinched the dual, ballooning Rutgers’ lead to 23–12 and sending the Scarlet Knights’ bench and home fans into celebration. The heavyweight bout that followed, a 4–2 decision for Minnesota’s Koy Hopke over Rutgers’ Hunter Catka, only trimmed the final margin to 23–15. The story of the night had already been written by Cotton’s overtime heroics.
On paper, this was an upset: No. 17 over No. 6. In reality, it was more than that. For Rutgers wrestling, the 23–15 victory checked several historic boxes that matter deeply within the sport.
National wrestling outlets took notice. Coverage from platforms like USA Wrestling’s TheMat.com highlighted Rutgers’ ability to flip multiple matches against higher-ranked Golden Gopher opponents and positioned the win as one of the marquee results in the early February dual slate. For a program working to build sustained national relevance, that type of attention matters.
To understand the full weight of this result, it helps to zoom out to the conference level. The Big Ten is widely regarded as the strongest wrestling conference in college sports, consistently producing NCAA team champions and a significant share of individual All-Americans. According to NCAA championship histories and Big Ten performance trends, programs like Penn State, Iowa, Ohio State, and Minnesota have set the standard for the sport for more than a decade.
In that context, a mid-ranked Big Ten team beating a top-six conference opponent is not just another upset. It is a signal that the middle of the league is closing the gap on its traditional powers. For Rutgers, it suggests that the investment in wrestling and Olympic sports, from facilities to recruiting resources to staff support, is paying off in tangible, scoreboard-level ways.
Head coach Scott Goodale has often emphasized that climbing in the Big Ten requires production from all ten weights and the ability to capitalize when an opportunity finally presents itself. Nights like this are where those philosophies are tested. Rutgers did not rely on a single superstar performance. Instead, the upset was built from:
The result also positions Rutgers more favorably in the national rankings and within the Big Ten postseason conversation. As the conference dual season wraps up and seeds for the Big Ten Championships are set, wins over highly ranked opponents can significantly influence both team seeding and individual placement lines.
The timing of this upset could prove just as important as the scoreline. Coming in early February, as the regular season yields to championship talk, signature wins carry magnified weight in coaches’ minds and ranking discussions.
For Rutgers wrestlers, this dual adds several résumé-defining results:
Team-wise, the upset over Minnesota should boost Rutgers’ perceived strength in national polls and ranking formulas used by coaches and media. As selection committees consider at-large bids and seeds for the NCAA Championships, a clear, high-profile victory over a top-six program is the kind of data point that stands out.
For athletes and families studying the college wrestling landscape, this is a real-time example of how quickly a program’s postseason ceiling can rise with one breakthrough dual. A strong February performance can turn a solid regular season into a springboard for podium runs in March.
From a recruiting perspective, this 23–15 victory over Minnesota sends a simple, powerful message: Rutgers is not just trying to survive in the Big Ten, it is capable of beating the league’s elite at home and building around a deep, competitive lineup.
For high school wrestlers and parents, several takeaways stand out:
If you are a prospective recruit or family trying to evaluate where a program like Rutgers fits in the broader wrestling landscape, it can help to use structured tools, not just headlines. Pathley’s College Fit Snapshot lets you run a quick fit check on a specific school, combining academic, athletic, and campus factors into one clear report. That can make it easier to see how a surging Big Ten program lines up with your goals.
Rutgers is just one example of how a wrestling program can surge into national relevance with the right mix of coaching, development, and conference opportunity. If this 23–15 upset over Minnesota has you thinking more seriously about Big Ten or Division I wrestling, there are a few concrete ways to explore your options.
Start with the Pathley Wrestling Hub, where you can explore college wrestling programs across divisions, compare schools, and get a sense of which conferences and regions match your level and goals. From there, tools like the Pathley College Directory and Compare Two Colleges page can help you narrow down a list of schools that fit both your wrestling ambitions and your academic interests.
If you are earlier in your process and just trying to understand how to present yourself to coaches, the Pathley Athletic Resume Builder can turn your stats, honors, and video links into a polished, coach-ready PDF in minutes. That way, when you see a program like Rutgers knocking off a top-six opponent and imagine yourself in that lineup, you are already prepared to reach out with a clear, organized profile.
For Rutgers wrestling, the challenge now is to turn one landmark upset into a new standard. The 23–15 win over Minnesota proves the Scarlet Knights can beat a top-six opponent in front of a raucous home crowd. The next step is stacking performances, competing for higher Big Ten placement, and sending larger groups of battle-tested wrestlers to the NCAA Championships each March.
The blueprint from this dual is clear:
For athletes and families watching from the outside, Rutgers’ upset of Minnesota is a reminder that the college wrestling landscape is dynamic. Programs can rise, seize their opportunities, and reshape expectations in a single night. With tools like the Pathley recruiting platform and Pathley Chat helping you search and evaluate schools more intelligently, you can track those shifts in real time and target programs where the trajectory and culture match your own competitive ambitions.
On February 6, 2026, Rutgers showed what it looks like when a program capitalizes on that moment. For wrestlers chasing their own Big Ten or NCAA dreams, the next step is deciding where you want your breakthrough night to happen and building a college list that makes it possible.
