College Search
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
College Search
On February 9, 2026, University of Colorado Boulder women’s lacrosse delivered the kind of result that can redefine an entire program. The Buffaloes went into Ryan Fieldhouse in Evanston, Illinois and upset No. 2 Northwestern 10–9, earning their first ever win over a top-five opponent and the highest-ranked victory in school history.
In just its 13th season as a varsity program, Colorado had never beaten a top-five team and had never won on Northwestern’s home field. The Buffaloes entered the matchup 0–8 all-time against teams ranked fifth or higher and just 1–5 against the Wildcats, including a lopsided 20–5 loss in Evanston almost exactly one year earlier. This time, they flipped the script in a game that could resonate throughout the Big 12 and national women’s lacrosse landscape.
To fully understand how significant this 10–9 win is, you have to look at where both programs were coming from.
Northwestern is one of the true blue bloods of NCAA Division I women’s lacrosse. The Wildcats captured the national championship in 2023 and finished as national runner-up in 2025, building on a long track record of dominance under head coach Kelly Amonte Hiller. They had already opened the 2026 season with a statement 20–12 victory over No. 3 Boston College, reinforcing their status near the top of the national rankings.
Colorado’s recent history told a different story. The Buffaloes went 8–8 in 2025 and missed the NCAA tournament, a reminder of how thin the margins can be for a program in the middle tier of the Division I landscape. Coming into Monday’s 2026 season opener, Colorado was still searching for its first breakthrough against the sport’s true elite.
Northwestern had dominated the series, and the numbers around top-five opponents were stark: 0–8 all-time for Colorado before this game. That is why this upset instantly becomes a program landmark for the Buffaloes and a performance that coaches, recruits, and fans will circle when they talk about the trajectory of Colorado women’s lacrosse.
From the opening draw, Colorado looked like the more composed and prepared team. The Buffaloes controlled the pace in the first quarter, getting quality looks on offense and turning Northwestern over in key spots.
Colorado landed six of its nine first-quarter shots on target while forcing seven Northwestern turnovers. That combination of efficiency and defensive pressure set the tone for an upset bid.
Attacker Teagan Ryan opened the scoring for the Buffaloes, putting them in front and quieting the home crowd. Seniors Rachel Kennedy and Maddie Shoup quickly added goals, giving Colorado a 3–0 lead by the 5:15 mark of the first quarter. For a Northwestern team used to dictating terms at home, especially indoors at Ryan Fieldhouse, it was a jarring start.
Northwestern did not record a shot on goal until late in the period, when sophomore attacker Aditi Foster finally broke through to cut the margin to 3–1. Even with that late goal, Colorado carried both the scoreboard edge and the emotional edge into the second quarter.
Colorado briefly extended its advantage early in the second quarter. Kennedy, capitalizing on a man-up opportunity, scored again to make it 4–1 and reinforce the sense that the Buffaloes were ready for the moment.
Northwestern responded with a stretch that looked more like its typical championship-caliber form. Midfielder Hannah Rudolph pulled the Wildcats within 4–2, giving the home side some momentum. Colorado answered through attacker Jaimey Hill, who converted a free-position attempt to push the lead to 5–2.
Still, Northwestern’s offense began to settle in. The Wildcats outshot Colorado 9–5 in the second quarter and started to tilt the stat sheet in their favor. In the final minute of the half, Northwestern capitalized with two quick-strike goals from Madison Taylor and Olivia Adamson, trimming the Buffaloes’ lead to 5–4 at the break.
Even as Northwestern surged late in the quarter, Colorado’s hustle stats remained impressive. The Buffaloes held the edge in caused turnovers and ground balls, a reflection of the work rate and physicality that would become even more important as the game tightened in the second half.
Coming out of halftime, Northwestern’s star senior attacker Madison Taylor reminded everyone why she is one of the most dangerous players in the country. Taylor led Division I in goals and points per game last season, and the third quarter in Evanston belonged almost entirely to her.
She tied the game less than a minute into the half and went on to score all four of Northwestern’s goals in the period. By the end of the third quarter, the Wildcats had turned a one-goal halftime deficit into an 8–6 lead, with Taylor’s individual brilliance front and center.
Northwestern’s domination on the draw also became more pronounced. The Wildcats built a 17–4 edge in draw controls by the end of the third quarter, the kind of statistical gap that typically spells trouble for any visiting team trying to close out an upset.
Yet Colorado stayed within striking distance. The Buffaloes’ defensive unit, backed by sophomore goalkeeper Elena Oh, refused to let the game get away. Disciplined team defense and timely stops helped limit Northwestern’s overall damage, even at a time when the home team had the ball far more often.
The final 15 minutes will go down as one of the defining quarters in Colorado women’s lacrosse history.
Trailing 8–6 and facing a Northwestern team accustomed to closing out tight games at home, Colorado’s seniors stepped into the spotlight. Shoup, a 5-foot-4 attacker and the Buffaloes’ leading returning scorer, took over the early stages of the fourth quarter.
She scored twice in the opening five minutes of the frame, erasing the deficit and tying the game at 8–8 with just over 10 minutes remaining. Those goals did more than just level the scoreboard; they shifted belief back to the Colorado sideline and signaled that the Buffaloes were not content to simply hang around.
Northwestern, unsurprisingly, turned once more to Taylor. She converted her sixth goal of the night off a feed from Taylor Lapointe, pushing the Wildcats back in front 9–8 with a little more than nine minutes to play. For many teams on the road, that might have been the moment the upset bid faded.
Colorado refused to let that happen.
Working another man-up situation after a Northwestern penalty, senior midfielder Lily Assini drove home the equalizer with 6:08 left, making it 9–9. It was a classic big-moment play from an experienced midfielder, capitalizing on a critical special-situation opportunity.
Northwestern controlled the ensuing draw and again tried to lean on its stars for a go-ahead goal. Instead, Oh produced one of the most important saves of the night, denying another Taylor attempt and sparking a clear the other way for Colorado.
With 4:25 remaining, Shoup authored the signature moment of her senior season. Attacking down the left side of the fan, she slipped a low shot between the legs of Northwestern goalkeeper Jenika Cuocco for her fifth goal and a 10–9 Colorado lead.
In a game defined by tiny margins, that finish stood up as the difference.
The work was not done after Shoup’s game-winner. Northwestern generated four shots in the final four minutes as it desperately tried to avoid a home loss, but Colorado’s defense and Oh held firm.
Oh made three saves down the stretch, including a last-ditch stop on Gabriella McCollester with just 10 seconds on the clock. That final denial capped an eight-save performance for the sophomore, five of which came in the fourth quarter alone, and preserved a result that instantly became the biggest win the Buffaloes have ever recorded.
The final statistics tell a story of a visiting team that refused to be intimidated by rankings, history or environment.
Despite a massive deficit on draws, Colorado narrowly outshot Northwestern and generated far more possessions by taking care of the ball and winning the hustle categories. Limiting turnovers to just 10 on the road against a high-pressure team like Northwestern is a major achievement, especially when the Wildcats coughed it up 18 times.
Individually, Shoup’s stat line stands out. She finished with five goals on six shots, recording the eighth hat trick of her career and clearly the most meaningful. Kennedy, playing her first game action since 2024, added two goals and an assist. Hill, Ryan and Assini chipped in one goal apiece, giving Colorado a balanced offensive effort around its senior stars.
On the defensive side, Oh’s eight saves and calm presence in the fourth quarter helped hold a prolific Northwestern attack under 10 goals at home for the first time in nearly a year.
After the game, Colorado head coach Ann Elliott Whidden framed the upset as the product of belief and preparation that had been building all preseason. She noted that it was hard to know exactly where her team stood until facing outside competition but emphasized that the Buffaloes had come into Evanston intent on playing their brand of lacrosse instead of worrying about rankings or revenge.
Whidden also pointed back to last season’s heavy loss in Evanston, praising her players for channeling that experience into better execution rather than emotion. The contrast between a 20–5 defeat and a 10–9 road win against essentially the same powerhouse opponent shows how quickly a mature roster can grow.
Shoup highlighted the work of the Colorado defense, particularly the efforts of defender Jess Peluso in disrupting passing lanes. She credited the unit’s ability to produce timely checks and knockdowns in the closing minutes, complementing Oh’s shot-stopping and making sure Northwestern never found the tying goal.
On the opposite sideline, Northwestern coach Kelly Amonte Hiller described the result as a lesson in humility and consistency. She acknowledged that the Wildcats did not start well enough and that Colorado was fully prepared to capitalize on any lapse in focus or energy.
For Colorado, this was more than one February upset. It could be a pillar of their 2026 postseason resume and a catalyst for a new era in Boulder.
The Buffaloes’ previous best win was a victory over then-No. 6 Penn State in 2017. Topping No. 2 Northwestern on the road not only surpasses that mark but also sends a loud message to poll voters, selection committees and future opponents: Colorado intends to be part of the national conversation this spring.
In a Big 12 landscape that is still evolving in women’s lacrosse, a result like this immediately elevates Colorado’s standing. Even if the Buffaloes take a few bumps in a long season, a road win over a recent national champion and current top-two team strengthens their at-large profile significantly, assuming they can stack solid conference and nonconference results around it.
Recruits and their families follow these kinds of games closely. Seeing a program like Colorado walk into Ryan Fieldhouse and beat Northwestern inevitably changes how prospects think about the Buffaloes. It suggests that Boulder is a place where you can both develop and compete with the very best.
For athletes and parents tracking the broader Division I landscape, resources like the Pathley Lacrosse Hub and the Pathley College Directory can help put performances like this in context, compare programs and identify schools where your own skills and goals might align.
Beyond the box score, Colorado’s upset of Northwestern offers several takeaways for high school players and club coaches thinking about college lacrosse and the recruiting process:
For student-athletes trying to figure out where they might fit in college, tools such as Pathley’s College Fit Snapshot and Compare Two Colleges can help you weigh programs like Colorado against other options in terms of academics, athletics and overall campus match.
Colorado will not have long to celebrate. With a home opener against Cornell up next, the Buffaloes now carry a target that did not exist a week ago. Opponents will see a 1–0 record paired with an elite road win and approach Colorado accordingly.
How the Buffaloes respond will say a lot about whether this victory is a start-of-season anomaly or the foundation for a sustained push toward the NCAA tournament. Their ability to maintain the defensive discipline, possession toughness and late-game poise they showed in Evanston will determine how far they go in 2026.
For now, though, the record book is clear: Colorado women’s lacrosse went into one of the sport’s most intimidating venues and walked out with the program’s first ever top-five win, a 10–9 classic that instantly joins the short list of the biggest early-season upsets in recent Division I women’s lacrosse history.
Northwestern’s place near the top of the sport has been well-documented by national outlets and the NCAA itself, which has chronicled the Wildcats’ title runs and sustained success over the past two decades. A home loss to an unranked or lower-ranked opponent always stands out, particularly early in the year when rankings and tournament projections are still being shaped.
National media have already taken notice of Colorado’s upset, with coverage on official athletic sites and independent outlets such as Sports Illustrated offering additional game details and reaction. When a rising program knocks off a perennial contender in February, it tends to recalibrate expectations for both teams and can influence seeding, at-large discussions and even recruiting battles months or years down the line.
For players and families trying to track these shifts and discover schools they might not have considered before, starting with tools like the Pathley Lacrosse Hub and exploring the full Pathley College Directory can make it much easier to see which programs are rising, which conferences are deepening and where new opportunities may be opening.
If Colorado’s breakthrough at Northwestern has you thinking differently about your own college lacrosse path, this is a good moment to zoom out and explore more options. Pathley’s tools are built to help athletes and families navigate exactly these kinds of questions.
When you are ready to turn inspiration into action, you can create a free profile and let Pathley’s AI help you organize targets, compare schools and sharpen your outreach to coaches. Upsets like Colorado’s win over Northwestern show how quickly the competitive map can change; having smart tools and clear information can help you find the right place in that evolving landscape.
